Skip to main content
How to Find the Equivalent of a Paint Color in Another Brand
How-ToCross-Brand MatchingColor Science

How to Find the Equivalent of a Paint Color in Another Brand

Updated
Philip Cameron
Save
How to Find the Equivalent of a Paint Color in Another Brand

Explore colors in this guide

Open a color for its details and cross-brand alternatives. Read on for the context behind each choice.

Trying to match a paint that is already on your wall? Start with how to match paint color on a wall. This guide covers the other case: you know the brand and color name and want its equivalent in a different brand.

To find a color's equivalent in another brand, look up the color on Paint Color HQ, where every color page displays CIEDE2000-calculated matches from all 13 brands in our 26,000+ color database, ranked from closest to farthest. A match labeled Nearly identical is hard to tell apart by eye. For example, Benjamin Moore White Dove (OC-17) matches to Sherwin-Williams Pure White (SW 7005) as Nearly identical, and Farrow & Ball Cornforth White (No. 228) matches to SW Repose Gray as Nearly identical. This guide explains the science, the tools, and the step-by-step process for finding accurate cross-brand equivalents.

Why You Need Cross-Brand Paint Matching

Cross-brand matching is essential in four scenarios: (1) a designer specifies Benjamin Moore but your contractor stocks Sherwin-Williams; (2) you move to an area where your brand is unavailable; (3) you want a Farrow & Ball color in a lower-priced brand such as Behr or Valspar; or (4) the original color has been discontinued and you need the closest surviving equivalent.

In all of these cases, you need more than an eyeball guess. You need science-backed color matching, and that's where Delta E comes in.

Why Paint Store Color Matching Falls Short

Paint stores scan a chip with a spectrophotometer and mix a custom color, but the result depends on the device's calibration, and in-store spectrophotometers drift between calibrations, producing errors you can notice side by side on a single scan. Custom-mixed colors also carry a hidden risk: batch-to-batch variation means a touch-up in two years will not match the original mix. Standard catalog colors are formulated to strict tolerances (typically held to a tolerance too tight to see batch-to-batch), making them far more reliable.

A better approach is to find the manufacturer's closest existing catalog color, which was specifically formulated and tested for their paint base. That's what Paint Color HQ helps you do: find the best standard color match, not a custom approximation.

Understanding Delta E and CIEDE2000 Color Science

Sherwin-Williams Agreeable Gray beside three other-brand colors: Behr Toasty Gray rated nearly identical, Benjamin Moore Light Pewter rated very similar, and Benjamin Moore Thornton Sage rated visible difference

Delta E (ΔE) measures the perceptual difference between two colors. The CIEDE2000 revision of the formula (which Paint Color HQ uses for every match calculation) is the gold standard in color science. Unlike simpler formulas that just compare RGB values, CIEDE2000 accounts for the fact that human eyes are more sensitive to some color differences than others. For example, we're more sensitive to differences in neutral tones (grays, beiges) than in saturated colors, and CIEDE2000 weights its calculations accordingly.

Here's what the closeness labels mean in practice:

Nearly identical. Imperceptible to most people, even side by side. Most homeowners would consider this an excellent match.
Very similar. Close, but you may notice a difference at a glance or side by side. Acceptable for rooms that won't be seen next to the original.
Visible difference. Most people would say these are different colors. Not recommended as a match.

Our database shows that the vast majority of popular colors from major brands have at least one cross-brand match rated Nearly identical, meaning you can almost always find an excellent equivalent. Browse our gray and beige color families to see how closely the top neutrals from different brands align.

Step-by-Step: How to Match Paint Colors on Paint Color HQ

Step 1: Identify your original color. Find the exact name, color code, and brand. Check the lid of the paint can, the receipt, or the designer's specification sheet. If you only have a photo or a physical sample, use our color identifier tool: upload an image and we'll identify the closest paint color in our database.

Step 2: Look up the color on Paint Color HQ. Use our color search to find it by name, color code, or hex value. You can also browse by brand: for example, the Sherwin-Williams catalog or Benjamin Moore catalog. Every color page automatically displays the closest matches from all 13 brands in our 26,000+ color database, ranked from closest to farthest.

Step 3: Review the closeness labels. We rate every suggested match Nearly identical, Very similar, or Visible difference. Look for Nearly identical for a barely visible difference. Very similar is acceptable for most residential projects where the original and the match won't be seen in the same room.

Step 4: Compare side by side. Use our color compare tool to place your original color next to its closest match. You'll see the closeness verdict, RGB values, undertone analysis, and a large visual comparison swatch: far more useful than squinting at tiny paint chips.

Step 5: Visualize it in your room. Before committing, preview the match in context with our room visualizer. Use one of the provided rooms to compare main-wall, accent-wall, and trim colors. It does not accept your own room photo or reproduce your lighting.

Step 6: Always sample. Even with a Nearly identical label, always paint a physical sample on your wall. Digital screens cannot perfectly represent paint colors, and factors like sheen, texture, and your room's lighting conditions affect the final result. Read our guide to paint color undertones for a deeper explanation of why colors shift in different lighting.

Real Examples: Popular Cross-Brand Matches

Let's walk through some of the most common cross-brand matching scenarios using real colors from our database.

Finding the Behr equivalent of Agreeable Gray. Agreeable Gray(Sherwin-Williams) (LRV 60, hex #D1CBC1) is a light warm greige. The closest Behr equivalent is Toasty Gray(Behr) (N320-2): a warm greige that rates nearly identical, meaning the two colors are hard to tell apart on a wall.

Matching Edgecomb Gray across brands. Edgecomb Gray(Benjamin Moore) (HC-173, LRV 63) is a light warm greige. Its closest Sherwin-Williams match is Agreeable Gray(Sherwin-Williams) (SW 7029, LRV 60) which rates very similar: close but perceptible side by side. Head to the Edgecomb Gray page to see all cross-brand matches ranked from closest to farthest.

Budget-friendly alternative to Farrow & Ball. Love Cornforth White(Farrow & Ball) (No. 228) but want a lower-priced brand? Its closest Sherwin-Williams match rates nearly identical, a close digital match to confirm with a sample. Check the Cornforth White page for all cross-brand matches ranked from closest to farthest.

Matching a classic white. White Dove(Benjamin Moore) is a soft warm white. A close Sherwin-Williams equivalent is Pure White(Sherwin-Williams), which rates nearly identical; SW Cold Foam (SW 9504) is closer still. Use the compare tool to see how close they are. For more on choosing whites, read our best white paint colors guide.

Navy blues across brands. Hale Navy(Benjamin Moore) is a deep navy for accent walls and cabinetry. If you need a Sherwin-Williams alternative, search for Hale Navy on our site and you'll find the closest SW navy ranked by Delta E. Explore more options in the blue color family, or browse the full BM to SW conversion chart for top crossovers across all color families.

When a Perfect Match Doesn't Exist

Some cross-brand searches return a closest match that is only Very similar or shows a Visible difference: most commonly with highly saturated greens, deep reds, and unusual accent colors. Popular neutrals (grays, beiges, whites) almost always have a Nearly identical match. When no nearly identical match exists, you have three options.

First, ask the paint store to custom-match using the original brand's color chip. This gives you the closest possible match in your preferred brand's paint base. Second, explore adjacent colors on Paint Color HQ: sometimes a slightly different shade actually works even better for your space. Use our palette generator to see how related colors work together in a full room scheme. Third, test the “imperfect” match on your wall: a color rated Very similar to your original often looks better in your specific room because of how your lighting, flooring, and furnishings interact with the undertone.

Common Mistakes When Matching Paint Colors

Matching by name alone. Color names are marketing, not science. “Agreeable Gray” and “Repose Gray” are both Sherwin-Williams grays, but they look noticeably different. Always match by closeness label, not by name. Use our color search to find matches based on the actual color values.

Ignoring undertones. Two colors can look similar on a screen but have completely different undertones: one might lean pink while the other leans green. This becomes obvious on a large wall. Our color pages show undertone analysis for every color, and our undertones guide explains why this matters.

Skipping the physical sample. No matter how close the label, always buy a sample pot and paint a 12-by-12-inch swatch on your actual wall. View it at different times of day: morning light, afternoon light, and artificial light at night. Colors shift dramatically based on lighting conditions. Read our guide to testing paint samples for the full process.

Forgetting about sheen. The same color in flat, eggshell, satin, and semi-gloss finishes will look different. Higher sheens reflect more light and tend to make colors look slightly lighter and more saturated. When comparing a match from another brand, make sure you're comparing the same sheen level.

Matching from a photo. Phone cameras and monitors distort color. If you're starting from a photo, use our color identifier as a starting point, but treat the result as a suggestion, not gospel. Confirm with a physical chip whenever possible.

Tips for Verifying Your Match with Physical Samples

Once you've identified a cross-brand match on Paint Color HQ, here's how to verify it in the real world. Buy sample pots of both your original color and the proposed match. Paint two large swatches (at least 12 by 12 inches) on the same wall, side by side. View them at four different times: early morning, midday with direct sun, late afternoon, and nighttime under your artificial lights. Pay attention to how the undertones shift: a color that looks the same at noon might diverge at sunset.

If you're matching across rooms (not placing the colors side by side), you have more flexibility. A Very similar rating is usually acceptable when the colors will be in separate spaces. Use the room visualizer to preview the matched color in context before buying samples.

Start Matching Colors Now

Cross-brand paint color matching is a solved problem. Paint Color HQ's 26,000+ color database spans 13 brands (Sherwin-Williams, Benjamin Moore, Behr, Valspar, PPG, Dunn-Edwards, and Farrow & Ball among them) and uses the CIEDE2000 formula (the same perceptual color-difference standard used by the International Commission on Illumination) to calculate every match. Start by searching for your color in our color search, or use the compare tool to evaluate any two colors side by side. If you're starting from a photo, try the color identifier, and use the paint calculator to figure out how much paint you'll need once you've found your match.

Frequently asked questions

What is Delta E in paint matching?
Delta E measures perceived color difference. Paint Color HQ uses the CIEDE2000 revision, the international color-science standard, and turns it into three plain labels: Nearly identical (hard to tell apart even side by side), Very similar (close, but you may notice it side by side), and Visible difference (clearly different colors).
How accurate are cross-brand paint color matches?
A Nearly identical or Very similar label indicates close digital colors. Physical paint may differ because of finish, tinting, substrate and lighting; compare samples before substituting brands.
Should I trust a custom-mixed paint match over a catalog match?
Catalog candidates and in-store custom matches both require sample testing. A digital shortlist does not establish which mixing method will produce a better physical match.
What's the best way to verify a paint color match in person?
Buy sample pots of both the original and the proposed match. Paint at least 12×12-inch swatches side-by-side on the same wall, then view them at four times of day: early morning, midday with direct sun, late afternoon, and nighttime under artificial light. Color shifts in different lighting often reveal differences that aren't visible on a chip.