One Color, Two Dozen Names: The Most Duplicated Paint Color in America
Explore colors in this guide
Open a color for its details and cross-brand alternatives. Read on for the context behind each choice.
Updated October 2026: the July run used outdated hex values for about 3,000 Behr, 1,100 Vista and 500 Valspar colors. We corrected them on 2026-10-11 and re-ran the study, which changed the originality ranking. Every figure below is from the October run.
We ran a simple question against our full database: how much of the American paint aisle is the same paint wearing different names? The dataset is every color we track, 26,720 colors across 13 brands, and the measure is CIEDE2000, the color-difference standard paint manufacturers use for quality control. We count two colors as twins only when their difference falls in the tightest half of our Nearly identical band: most people cannot tell them apart even side by side. The answer: 18,616 colors, 69.7% of everything we track, have at least one nearly identical twin at a competing brand.

The Most Duplicated Color in America
The single most duplicated color is a warm, slightly creamy off-white. Benjamin Moore sells it as Flurry (CC-100). Dunn-Edwards sells the same hex value, so the digital data cannot tell the two apart, as Swan White (DEW346). In total, 12 of the 13 brands we track sell a version of this shade close enough that you could swap one for another mid-wall and never spot the seam: at least two dozen named colors in all. That list includes one of the most famous designer whites in the world: Farrow & Ball's Pointing (2003), a premium-priced classic that is, colorimetrically, the same shade as the big-box versions below.
| Brand | Their name for it | How close |
|---|---|---|
| Benjamin Moore | Flurry CC-100 | the reference |
| Dunn-Edwards | Swan White DEW346 | Same hex value |
| Vista Paint | Abstract White 1027 | Nearly identical |
| Farrow & Ball | Pointing 2003 | Nearly identical |
| Sherwin-Williams | Roman Column 7562 | Nearly identical |
| Valspar | Warm Milk 8007-8B | Nearly identical |
| Dutch Boy | Aged Marble 006W | Nearly identical |
| Hirshfield's | Abstract White 1027 | Nearly identical |
| Behr | Spun Cotton YL-W09 | Nearly identical |
| PPG | White Chip 15-06 | Nearly identical |
| Kilz | Mayo LD200-01 | Nearly identical |
| RAL (standard) | 9001 Cream | Nearly identical |
One twin shown per brand, each compared with Flurry using CIEDE2000 and rated nearly identical. Colorhouse is the only tracked brand without one.
815 Hex Codes Are Sold by More Than One Brand
Nearly identical undersells some of it. 815 exact color values, the same hex digit for digit, are sold by two or more brands under different names, covering 1,698 named paint colors. In the most extreme case, four brands sell the same exact value. Flurry and Swan White above are one of those pairs: not close, not similar, but the same color target with two names and two price tags.
The Most (and Least) Original Palettes
Flip the question: what share of each brand's palette exists nowhere else, with no nearly identical twin at any other tracked brand? Dunn-Edwards leads at 37.8%. Valspar, Behr and Benjamin Moore are close behind at about 34%, and Hirshfield's trails at 14.8%.
| Brand | Palette size | Colors unique to the brand |
|---|---|---|
| Dunn-Edwards | 2,230 | 37.8% |
| Valspar | 2,358 | 33.9% |
| Behr | 5,789 | 33.6% |
| Benjamin Moore | 3,903 | 33.5% |
| PPG | 3,261 | 30.1% |
| Colorhouse | 128 | 28.1% |
| Kilz | 827 | 27.1% |
| Sherwin-Williams | 1,950 | 25.7% |
| Farrow & Ball | 167 | 25.1% |
| Dutch Boy | 1,441 | 25.1% |
| Vista Paint | 2,984 | 23.7% |
| Hirshfield's | 1,469 | 14.8% |
Palette size counts retired colors, which can usually still be mixed by code; that is why Behr shows 5,789. RAL is excluded here because it is an industrial color standard, not a decorative paint line. Two honest caveats: a bigger palette naturally claims more unique territory, which helps Behr and Benjamin Moore, the two largest; and regional brands like Hirshfield's and Vista Paint serve customers who ask for national colors by name, so tracking those palettes closely is part of the job, not a knock on them. Dunn-Edwards tops the ranking with a mid-sized palette of 2,230 colors.
Even the premium end converges: about three-quarters of Sherwin-Williams and Farrow & Ball colors have a nearly identical twin somewhere else. The most intertwined pair of brands is Behr and Benjamin Moore: 1,594 Behr colors have a nearly identical Benjamin Moore counterpart, and 1,412 Benjamin Moore colors have a Behr one.
Why the Paint Aisle Converges
Three forces push palettes together. First, demand piles up in a small corner of color space: whites, off-whites, greiges, and soft grays dominate what people put on walls, so every brand needs dense coverage exactly there. Second, matching a competitor's bestseller is normal practice: paint stores field “can you make Agreeable Gray?” requests every day, and brands answer by shipping their own version. Third, regional brands maintain equivalents of the national palettes their customers name-check. The result is a market where the name and the can are brand-specific, but the color itself often is not.
What This Means When You're Buying Paint
You are less locked in than the sample-card racks suggest. If you love a color but prefer another brand's price, availability, or a specific product line, there is roughly a 70% chance a nearly identical version exists. Every color page on this site lists them, and the compare tool shows any two candidates side by side. The one thing the math cannot standardize is the paint itself: formulas, sheens, and coverage differ between brands even when the color target is the same, so confirm the winner with a physical sample on your own wall before buying gallons.
Methodology
We computed CIEDE2000 differences across all 26,720 colors in the Paint Color HQ database, 12 decorative paint brands plus the RAL classic standard, as of October 2026. A color counts as twinned when its closest match at any other paint brand falls in the tightest half of our Nearly identical band. A RAL match does not count as a twin, though RAL colors stay in the total, and the exact-hex count includes RAL. Palette sizes include colors a brand has retired but can usually still mix by code. Color values come from each brand's published palette data; the conversion pipeline and thresholds are documented on our methodology page, and the same figures feed our paint color statistics. Brand palettes change, so counts shift slightly as we import updates. If you cite these findings, please link to this page so readers can check the current numbers.
Addendum: How Many Distinct Colors Are There, Really?
A sharp reader question after the July publication: does “two-thirds are duplicates” mean only a third of the catalog is unique, or that the whole catalog collapses to a third of its size once you merge duplicates? Those are different numbers, and the headline stat is the first one. In the October 2026 run, 69.7% of catalog entries have at least one nearly identical counterpart at a competing brand, and 30.3% (8,104 colors) have none.
The second question, how many distinct colors the market actually contains, is trickier, because near-identity is not transitive: color A can be a twin of B, and B of C, while A and C are visibly different. Merge every chain and one long run of whites, off-whites and greiges forms whose endpoints are clearly not the same color. The July version of this addendum gave a clustered estimate of distinct colors. That figure came from a one-off clustering pass we cannot reproduce on the corrected data, so we have withdrawn it rather than restate it. The honest summary: about 30% of entries are duplicated nowhere, about 70% are duplicated somewhere, and any single count of distinct colors depends on where you draw the line.
Frequently asked questions
- What counts as the same color in this analysis?
- A color counts as twinned in this study when its closest match at another brand has a CIEDE2000 difference in the tightest half of our Nearly identical band, a gap most people cannot see even with the two swatches side by side. CIEDE2000 is the perceptual color-difference standard used in paint manufacturing quality control. Paint formulas, sheens, and bases still differ between brands even when the color target is effectively the same.
- Are cheaper paint brands copying expensive ones?
- The data shows convergence, not intent. Popular neutrals cluster in a small region of color space, brands routinely match competitors' bestsellers on request, and regional brands often track the national palettes closely. Whether any given twin is imitation or coincidence, the numbers alone can't say.
- How do I find another brand's version of a paint color?
- Open any color on Paint Color HQ and its page lists the closest equivalent in every brand we track, ranked by perceptual closeness. You can also compare any two colors side by side with the compare tool. Because formulas and sheens differ, always confirm the final choice with a physical sample on your wall.
- How many distinct paint colors are there in America?
- The 13 brands Paint Color HQ tracks publish 26,720 named colors. As of October 2026, 30.3% of them (8,104) have no nearly identical twin at any other brand, and the other 69.7% do. We do not publish a single count of distinct colors, because near-identity chains: two colors can each be a twin of a third without being twins of each other, so any merged total depends on where you draw the 'same color' line.
- Which paint brand has the most original palette?
- Dunn-Edwards has the most original palette: 37.8% of its colors have no nearly identical twin at any other brand, followed closely by Valspar, Behr and Benjamin Moore at about 34%. Hirshfield's has the least, at 14.8%. These are October 2026 figures, re-run after we corrected outdated hex values; the July 2026 version of this study ranked Behr first on those outdated values.

