Alabaster vs. White Dove and 15 Other Famous Whites, Measured
Explore colors in this guide
Open a color for its details and cross-brand alternatives. Read on for the context behind each choice.
Sherwin-Williams Alabaster and Benjamin Moore White Dove rate Nearly identical on the color values each brand publishes, but neither is the other's closest match: White Dove's closest Sherwin-Williams color is Cold Foam (SW 9504). That is one of several answers we got by measuring the 17 most-searched whites in America with CIEDE2000, the color-difference standard paint manufacturers use for quality control. White is the color family where the internet argues hardest about whether two names are “basically the same,” so the numbers below settle some long-running debates and start at least one new one.

Alabaster vs. White Dove: Closer Than Their Reputations
The most-asked white-paint question there is, and the data gives a clean answer: Alabaster (SW 7008) and White Dove (OC-17) rate Nearly identical on the color values each brand publishes. White Dove is slightly lighter (LRV 83.2 vs 82.2) and a touch less yellow (LAB b* 4.5 to Alabaster's 5.2). Both are soft whites that lean slightly warm, and both sit in the middle of the famous-white pack for warmth rather than at the creamy end. A digital match is not wet paint, so put physical samples of both on the same wall before swapping one for the other mid-project.
The Secret Twins
Meanwhile, pairs almost nobody compares turn out to be nearly the same color:
| Pair | Difference | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| BM Cloud White + Behr Swiss Coffee | Nearly identical | A premium classic and a big-box staple, effectively one color |
| SW Alabaster + SW Greek Villa | Nearly identical | Same brand. If you are agonizing between these two, stop |
| BM Chantilly Lace + Behr Polar Bear | Nearly identical | Crisp whites across a large price gap |
| SW Alabaster + BM Swiss Coffee | Nearly identical | The cross-brand swap for Alabaster loyalists in a Benjamin Moore store |
Same Name, Different Color
Six of the thirteen brands we track sell a color named “Swiss Coffee”, and they are not the same paint. Benjamin Moore's Swiss Coffee (OC-45) and Behr's Swiss Coffee (12) rate nearly identical, though Behr's runs lighter. The name is a category, not a formula: the same trap as “Antique White,” which eight brands sell under that exact name. (More of these in our paint color statistics.)
The Whitest White You Can Buy
Every brand has a ceiling, the lightest white it sells, and the ceilings differ more than you would expect. Among brands that publish LRV, the top published value is 94, shared by Behr Ultra Pure White and two other Behr whites, Stately White and Blanca Peak. Sherwin-Williams' brightest, UltraWhite, is published at 93.5. PPG's lightest white is published at 89, about five points below Behr's. And if what you want is white with no undertone at all, the truest white we measured is Dunn-Edwards Lighthouse, nearly chroma-free; Dunn-Edwards publishes LRV 83.
Which Brand's Whites Run Warmest
Averaging the warmth of every white each brand sells (4,244 colors at LRV 75+), a brand personality shows up. Sherwin-Williams' whites run the coolest of any brand (average b* 7.8): despite Alabaster's warm reputation, the SW white wall leans crisp. Hirshfield's (11.8) and Vista Paint (10.9) run warmest, with Benjamin Moore in the middle of the pack (10.0). Among the famous whites themselves, Farrow & Ball Pointing is the warmest. Practical version: if you keep landing on whites that feel too cold, shop the warm half of the market; if your whites keep going cream on you, Sherwin-Williams' and Behr's cooler ranges are where to look.
How to Use This
Treat the map above as a shortlist tool: pick the warmth-and-lightness neighborhood your room needs, take the two or three names that live there, and compare them side by side. Then order physical samples of the finalists and look at them on your wall morning and evening: whites shift with window direction and bulb temperature more than any other color family. Our guide to paint undertones covers how to read what a white is doing in your light.
Methodology
Color differences are CIEDE2000 computed from each brand's published color values; warmth is LAB b*; the whites universe is every color at LRV 75 or above across the 13 brands we track (4,244 colors) as of October 2026. The brightest-white figures are each manufacturer's published LRV. Method details are on our methodology page; the cross-brand duplication analysis this builds on is in our study of duplicated paint colors. Published values describe the color target, not the liquid paint: sheen, texture, and pigment recipe still differ between brands, so confirm finalists with physical samples. If you cite this comparison, please link to this page.
Frequently asked questions
- Is Sherwin-Williams Alabaster the same as Benjamin Moore White Dove?
- Not the same paint, but very close. Using each brand's published color values, they rate Nearly identical with CIEDE2000. White Dove is slightly lighter (LRV 83.2 against 82.2) and a touch less yellow than Alabaster. Confirm with physical samples on your own wall before swapping one for the other mid-project.
- What is the whitest white paint you can buy?
- Among the brands that publish LRV, the highest published light reflectance is 94, shared by Behr Ultra Pure White, Behr's base white, and two other Behr whites, Stately White and Blanca Peak. Sherwin-Williams UltraWhite is close behind at 93.5. Every brand's ceiling differs: PPG's lightest white, Soft Candlelight, is published at LRV 89, about five points lower.
- Which paint brand has the warmest whites?
- Averaged across every white each brand sells (LRV 75+), Sherwin-Williams' whites run the coolest and Hirshfield's the warmest. Benjamin Moore sits in the middle of the pack. The warmest of the famous whites is Farrow & Ball Pointing. If you want creamy whites, look at Hirshfield's and Vista Paint or a warm classic like Pointing; if you want crisp gallery whites, Sherwin-Williams and Behr lean cool.

