Skip to main content
Sherwin-Williams vs Benjamin Moore: The Complete Comparison
BrandsComparisonBuying Guide

Sherwin-Williams vs Benjamin Moore: The Complete Comparison

Updated
Philip Cameron
Save
Sherwin-Williams vs Benjamin Moore: The Complete Comparison

Explore colors in this guide

Open a color for its details and cross-brand alternatives. Read on for the context behind each choice.

Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore are the two premium brands most homeowners weigh against each other. Both make good paint. They differ in how you buy it, how big the palette is, and which products suit cabinets and exteriors. This guide covers each factor, and every color pair below comes from our cross-brand match data.

Price: Get a Current Quote

We do not list per-gallon prices, because both brands change them by line, by store and through the year. Get a quote for the exact line and sheen you want from your local Sherwin-Williams store and a Benjamin Moore dealer.

Compare like with like: Benjamin Moore Regal Select against Sherwin-Williams SuperPaint, and Benjamin Moore Aura against Sherwin-Williams Emerald.

Matched Color Pairs

The fastest way to compare the two palettes is through well-known colors and their closest match in the other brand:

Agreeable Gray(Sherwin-Williams) ↔ Revere Pewter(Benjamin Moore): Two warm greiges, rated Very similar: close, but sample them side by side before you swap one for the other. Browse the gray color family.

Pure White(Sherwin-Williams) ↔ White Dove(Benjamin Moore): Both soft whites that lean slightly warm, and they rate nearly identical. See the white color family.

Alabaster(Sherwin-Williams) ↔ Simply White(Benjamin Moore): Warm whites for whole-house color. Very similar in our digital data.

Naval(Sherwin-Williams) ↔ Hale Navy(Benjamin Moore): Two deep navies. Naval is slightly cooler and more saturated; Hale Navy has a hint of green that makes it pair more easily with warm woods. Rated Visible difference, so they are not interchangeable.

Accessible Beige(Sherwin-Williams) ↔ Edgecomb Gray(Benjamin Moore): Two warm greiges for whole-home neutral walls. Edgecomb has slightly more green; Accessible Beige reads slightly warmer.

Repose Gray(Sherwin-Williams) ↔ Classic Gray(Benjamin Moore): Two light grays. Repose has more brown and is the deeper of the two; Classic Gray reads slightly cooler and lighter.

Tricorn Black(Sherwin-Williams) ↔ Black Beauty(Benjamin Moore): Two blacks for trim, doors, and accent walls. Tricorn is a true neutral black; Black Beauty has the faintest blue cast.

Extra White(Sherwin-Williams) ↔ Chantilly Lace(Benjamin Moore): Two crisp whites that rate nearly identical, with Chantilly Lace the brighter of the two. Both read clean with no obvious undertone. Excellent for trim against any wall color.

Use our color compare tool to see how close any SW and BM colors are. Read our undertones guide to understand why similar-looking colors can feel different on your walls. For a systematic view, browse the full SW to BM conversion chart or the BM to SW chart for the 50 closest pairs.

Paint Lines

Both brands make premium paint, and at the top tier the differences are small enough that prep and application matter more than the label. Compare the data sheets for the lines you are considering: coverage per gallon, recoat time and washability are listed there.

For cabinets and trim, each brand sells a dedicated enamel, covered in the cabinets section below.

Color Selection

Benjamin Moore: 3,903 colors in our database. The larger palette, with a deep range of whites, neutrals, and historically inspired shades.

Sherwin-Williams: 1,950 colors in our database. A smaller, more curated selection. Either brand's store can mix the other brand's color; see the color matching section below.

On Paint Color HQ, every color page shows the closest matches from both brands automatically. Our SW alternatives to BM's top sellers covers the common crossovers.

Availability

SW is easier to buy. Sherwin-Williams sells through its own stores, which keep evening and weekend hours. Benjamin Moore sells through independent dealers, so hours and stock vary from store to store.

The Color Matching Question

Can you take a BM color to an SW store (or vice versa)? Yes: both stores can spectrophotometer-match any physical chip. But a custom-matched color isn't the same as a formulated color. For the best result, find the brand's closest existing color using our cross-brand search, then sample both the original and the match. For a curated view, browse the full SW to BM conversion chart or the reverse BM to SW chart: both show the 50 closest cross-brand matches ranked by Delta E.

Who Should Choose SW

You value convenience (company-owned stores with longer hours), your contractor already has an SW account, or you prefer a smaller, curated palette. Explore all Sherwin-Williams colors.

Who Should Choose BM

You want the larger palette, you are painting cabinets and want Advance, your designer specified BM colors, or you prefer an independent paint store for advice. Browse all Benjamin Moore colors.

Cabinets and Trim Deep Dive

Cabinet and trim paint is the one category where the brand choice meaningfully affects the result. Wall paint can be touched up; cabinets cannot. The wrong product on a kitchen cabinet means stripping and starting over.

Benjamin Moore Advance is the cabinet and trim enamel Benjamin Moore describes as a waterborne alkyd: it levels like an oil-based paint and cleans up with water. It hardens slowly, so read the cure time on its data sheet before you rehang doors or load shelves.

Sherwin-Williams Emerald Urethane Trim Enamel is SW's equivalent, and ProClassic Waterbased is SW's other trim enamel. Compare open time and recoat time on the two data sheets if you are brushing large cabinet doors.

For both brands, the prep work matters more than the paint. On previously-painted cabinets, sand to scuff the finish, clean with TSP or denatured alcohol, and prime with an oil-based or shellac-based primer (such as Zinsser BIN) before applying topcoat. Skip it and the topcoat can chip and peel. Read our paint sheen guide: for cabinets, satin or semi-gloss is standard.

Exterior Paint: Different Trade-Offs

Exterior paint inverts some of the interior trade-offs. Weatherability, UV stability, and washability matter more than leveling. Both brands have premium exterior lines, but their strengths differ.

Benjamin Moore Aura Exterior is Benjamin Moore's top exterior line, and Sherwin-Williams Emerald is SW's. For dark exterior colors such as navy and charcoal, compare each line's data sheet for fade resistance, and read the warranty terms for your siding material before you buy.

If rain could interrupt the job, look at the fast rain-resistant products. Benjamin Moore says Element Guard resists rain as soon as 60 minutes after application, and Sherwin-Williams sells Emerald Rain Refresh for the same problem; check its data sheet for the timing.

For front doors specifically, Benjamin Moore sells Aura Grand Entrance as a door and trim enamel. Read our best exterior paint colors guide for color picks specifically for siding, trim, and shutters.

Working Out What a Project Costs

Start with how much paint the job needs. Here is a typical 12x12 bedroom with 8-foot ceilings (walls only, 2 coats):

Bedroom walls: 384 sq ft of wall area, minus 1 door (21 sq ft) and 2 windows (30 sq ft) = 333 sq ft per coat × 2 coats = 666 sq ft. At 350 sq ft per gallon, that's 2 gallons of wall paint. Run the numbers in our paint calculator with your actual dimensions for exact gallons.

Multiply the gallons by your current quote for each line. For a whole-house repaint with about 2,400 sq ft of wall area, two coats come to roughly 14 gallons, so a few dollars of difference per gallon adds up.

The Best of Both Worlds

You do not have to pick one brand for the whole house. For example, you can use Advance on cabinets and trim and Sherwin-Williams paint on the walls. Use our compare tool to make sure your BM trim white matches your SW wall color. Our palette generator can help you build a cohesive scheme mixing colors from either brand. To preview any combination in a real room before buying samples, try the room visualizer.

Frequently asked questions

Is Sherwin-Williams or Benjamin Moore better?
Both make premium paint, and at the top tier prep and application matter more than the label. Sherwin-Williams is easier to buy, through its own stores; Benjamin Moore has the larger palette and sells through independent dealers. Compare like-for-like lines (Aura against Emerald, Regal Select against SuperPaint) and get current quotes for each.
Can I get a Benjamin Moore color in Sherwin-Williams paint (or vice versa)?
Yes - both stores can spectrophotometer-match any physical chip and mix the color in their own paint base. But a custom mix isn't the same as a formulated catalog color: in-store spectrophotometers can drift enough to show between calibrations, and batch-to-batch consistency for custom mixes is weaker. For best results, find the brand's closest catalog equivalent first - see the SW to BM and BM to SW conversion charts.
Which brand is better for kitchen cabinets?
Each brand sells a cabinet enamel: Benjamin Moore Advance, which Benjamin Moore describes as a waterborne alkyd, and Sherwin-Williams Emerald Urethane Trim Enamel, with ProClassic Waterbased as a second SW option. Whichever you pick, previously painted cabinets need sanding, cleaning and an oil-based or shellac-based primer such as Zinsser BIN before the topcoat.
Which brand is better for exterior paint?
Aura Exterior is Benjamin Moore's top exterior line and Emerald is Sherwin-Williams'. Compare their data sheets for fade resistance on dark colors and read each warranty for your siding material. If rain is a scheduling risk, look at the fast rain-resistant products: Benjamin Moore says Element Guard resists rain as soon as 60 minutes after application, and Sherwin-Williams sells Emerald Rain Refresh for the same job.