Both understated and nuanced, Plum Island is a deep, muted warm gray with soft pink undertones. With an LRV of 25, it creates a cocooning effect, perfect for moody bedrooms, libraries, and intimate dining rooms. Benjamin Moore offers Plum as an extremely close match, while Vista Paint's Midnight Affair is also very similar. It pairs well with crisp whites for contrast and warm metallics like brass or gold for cohesion.
Suggested Color Palettes
Color harmonies based on color theory — each swatch links to the closest matching paint.
Opposite on the color wheel — creates vibrant contrast
Closest Matches from Other Brands
Closest digital match based on color values. Pigments and finishes differ between brands — always verify with physical samples.